Neighborhood

New Monterey, Monterey, CA

Neighborhood RatingNeighborhood RatingNeighborhood RatingNeighborhood RatingNeighborhood Rating
3.6 /5

Neighborhood Factors

Market Conditions

  • Neighborhood Factors
    Price
    $1.08M
  • Neighborhood Factors
    Value
    -
  • Neighborhood Factors
    Appreciation
    -3%

New Monterey at a Glance

New Monterey is ranked #5 of 16 neighborhoods in Monterey with an overall score of 3.6/5. Its standout factors are nearby merchants (4.2/5) and safety (4.1/5, 6th of 16 in Monterey). The trade-off is curb appeal (3.3/5).

New Monterey Reviews & Questions

Neighborhood Review
Key Words: Lighthouse Avenue, Hilltop Park, Presidio Park

New Monterey is built around Lighthouse Avenue, the working street between Old Town and Pacific Grove, in the northwest part of Monterey. The street has the feel of a place people actually shop and eat along, right beside the visitor crowds on Cannery Row. New Monterey's residential streets sit behind the avenue, broken up by small neighborhood parks. Hilltop Park covers 2.8 acres with a large grass field, a fenced toddler playground, basketball and tennis courts and a group barbecue. Oak Newton Park and Archer Park add play equipment and basketball, Archer Park also has restrooms and a ballfield for baseball and softball, and Cypress Park fills in the gaps. Lower Presidio Historic Park sits near the Presidio of Monterey, which gives the area an older layer under the shops. Lighthouse Avenue is where the food is. The Perfect Crumb, at 301 Lighthouse, has been baking key lime pie and almond croissants since 2016, and right beside it Paprika Cafe seats about six tables and is known for spanakopita, baba ghanoush and a vegan baklava. Gianni's Pizza, at 725 Lighthouse, has been making hand-tossed pies since 1974. El Cantaro, on Foam Street, is a vegan Mexican kitchen known for crispy potato tacos and house-made salsas and moles. Errands run along the same avenue, which also holds International Cafe at 296 Lighthouse for gyros, shawarma and falafel, and Hula's Island Grill at 622 Lighthouse for poke and tropical cocktails. Highway 1 is close for trips toward Carmel or Santa Cruz, and Monterey-Salinas Transit covers the local bus service. Being this close to Cannery Row and the aquarium means visitors share the streets, and the avenue gets busier because of it. Still, a bakery that has operated since 2016 and a pizzeria going since 1974 show the avenue serves the people nearby as much as the tourists.

See City Review for: Monterey

Top Neighborhoods in Monterey, CA

1st
Map placeholder for Old Town, Monterey - not a photo of the neighborhood
Old Town, Monterey, CA
Overall Score : 3.7
Old Town keeps the look Monterey had in its earliest days, and living here means... See Full Page
2nd
Map placeholder for Aguajito Oaks, Monterey - not a photo of the neighborhood
Aguajito Oaks, Monterey, CA
Overall Score : 3.6
Aguajito Oaks sits in the southeast part of Monterey, and the name is accurate. ... See Full Page
3rd
Map placeholder for Del Monte Beach, Monterey - not a photo of the neighborhood
Del Monte Beach, Monterey, CA
Overall Score : 3.6
Del Monte Beach is the part of Monterey that sits right against the sand, where ... See Full Page

New Monterey Amenities

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Near good merchants

    4.2

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Public Spaces

    3.7

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Curb Appeal

    3.3

Overall Amenities score: 3.6

New Monterey Weather

75%
of possible sunshine
Of all the daylight this spot gets in a year, 75% arrives as sunshine - clouds and fog block the rest.
New Monterey ranks 7th of 16 for sunshine in Monterey, and it out-suns about a third of the Monterey Bay area. Its warmest month is September, averaging 68° highs, and it gets about 19 inches of rain a year.
Average daily high and low temperature
70°60°50°40°JFMAMJJASONDSep 68°
Avg highAvg low
Rank in Monterey
7th of 16
Across the Monterey Bay area
30th percentile
Rain per year
19 in
Warmest month
Sep 68° avg high
Summer day
53° → 66°F
Winter day
43° → 61°F
Sunshine and temperature figures are 30-year climate averages for this neighborhood's location.

New Monterey Photos

Schools Serving New Monterey

School NameTypeGradesHouseberry School Score

No Data Found

Click links for school listing

info at GreatSchools.org

Houseberry School Score Data

from CA Dept. of Education

Houseberry recommends using these scores as only a starting point, and conducting your own investigation into what schools fit best for your preferences. School boundaries are not guaranteed and may change. It is important to contact the appropriate school district to confirm enrollment eligibility before making any decision to move to a neighborhood.

New Monterey FAQs

7 answers

Is New Monterey a good place to live?

New Monterey ranks 5th of 16 neighborhoods in Monterey with an overall Houseberry score of 3.6 out of 5. Its strongest factors are nearby merchants (4.2/5) and safety (4.1/5). The trade-off is curb appeal (3.3/5).

Is New Monterey safe?

New Monterey, Monterey scores 4.1 out of 5 on Houseberry's Safety Score, ranking 6th of 16 neighborhoods in Monterey.

What is the weather like in New Monterey?

New Monterey, Monterey receives 75% of its possible sunshine, 7th of 16 in Monterey. Summer days run 53° to 66°F and winter days 43° to 61°F, September is the warmest month and rainfall averages about 19 inches a year.

Is New Monterey walkable to shops and restaurants?

New Monterey, Monterey scores 4.2 out of 5 for nearby merchants and 3.7 out of 5 for public spaces. Its overall amenities score is 3.6 out of 5, 5th of 16 in Monterey.

What is New Monterey known for?

New Monterey, Monterey is associated with Lighthouse Avenue, Hilltop Park and Presidio Park. Its highest-scoring factors are nearby merchants (4.2/5) and safety (4.1/5).

How does New Monterey compare to other Monterey neighborhoods?

New Monterey ranks 5th of 16 neighborhoods in Monterey. It ranks 6th of 16 in Monterey for safety (4.1/5) and scores lowest on curb appeal (3.3/5). The next-ranked neighborhoods in Monterey are Skyline Forest and Skyline Ridge Estates.

What are the downsides of living in New Monterey?

New Monterey, Monterey scores lowest on curb appeal (3.3/5).

Follow this neighborhood for updates
New Monterey Photos
Top Neighborhoods in Monterey, CA
1st
Map placeholder for Old Town, Monterey - not a photo of the neighborhood
Old Town, Monterey, CA
Overall Score : 3.7
Old Town keeps the look Monterey had in its earliest days, and living here means... See Full Page
2nd
Map placeholder for Aguajito Oaks, Monterey - not a photo of the neighborhood
Aguajito Oaks, Monterey, CA
Overall Score : 3.6
Aguajito Oaks sits in the southeast part of Monterey, and the name is accurate. ... See Full Page
3rd
Map placeholder for Del Monte Beach, Monterey - not a photo of the neighborhood
Del Monte Beach, Monterey, CA
Overall Score : 3.6
Del Monte Beach is the part of Monterey that sits right against the sand, where ... See Full Page

New Monterey Map

Loading map...

View Full Map

Contact Houseberry's 2026 Agent Pick for New Monterey
Follow this neighborhood for updates