Alto Sutton Manor, Mill Valley, CA
At a glance
Alto Sutton Manor is ranked #14 of 17 neighborhoods in Mill Valley with an overall score of 4.1/5. Its standout factors are schools (4.7/5, 11th of 17 in Mill Valley) and safety (3.9/5). The trade-offs are nearby merchants (3.0/5) and curb appeal (3.0/5).
Neighborhood Reviews & Questions
Tucked between Highway 101 and Mill Valley’s more central neighborhoods, Alto Sutton Manor is a small but strategically located area that appeals to those who value quick commutes and proximity to conveniences. This neighborhood features a mix of ranch-style and mid-century homes, with some newer builds as well. Though compact, it punches above its weight when it comes to accessibility—Whole Foods, the Mill Valley-Sausalito Path, and both Mill Valley and Strawberry Village amenities are just minutes away. It’s also home to Edna Maguire Elementary School, which is a major asset for families. The area borders the Horse Hill Preserve, giving residents nearby trails and open space despite the urban-adjacent setting.
Top Neighborhoods in Mill Valley, CA
Neighborhood Amenities
Near good merchants3.0
Public Spaces3.5
Curb Appeal3
Overall Amenities score: 3.2
Neighborhood Weather
Neighborhood Photos
1 of 4
Schools serving this Neighborhood
| School Name | Type | Grades | Houseberry School Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Edna Maguire Elementary | Primary | K-5 | |
| Old Mill Elementary | Primary | K-5 | |
| Park Elementary | Primary | K-5 | |
| Strawberry Point Elementary | Primary | K-5 | |
| Tamalpais Valley Elementary | Primary | K-5 | |
| Mill Valley Middle | Middle | 6-8 | |
| Tamalpais High | High | 9-12 |
Click links for school listing
info at GreatSchools.org
Houseberry School Score Data
from CA Dept. of Education
Houseberry recommends using these scores as only a starting point, and conducting your own investigation into what schools fit best for your preferences. School boundaries are not guaranteed and may change. It is important to contact the appropriate school district to confirm enrollment eligibility before making any decision to move to a neighborhood.
Alto Sutton Manor FAQs8 answers
Is Alto Sutton Manor a good place to live?
Alto Sutton Manor ranks 14th of 17 neighborhoods in Mill Valley with an overall Houseberry score of 4.1 out of 5. Its strongest factors are schools (4.7/5) and safety (3.9/5). The trade-offs are nearby merchants (3.0/5) and curb appeal (3.0/5).
Is Alto Sutton Manor safe?
Alto Sutton Manor, Mill Valley scores 3.9 out of 5 on Houseberry's Safety Score, ranking 12th of 17 neighborhoods in Mill Valley.
Which schools serve Alto Sutton Manor?
Schools serving Alto Sutton Manor, Mill Valley include Edna Maguire Elementary (4.3/5), Old Mill Elementary (5.0/5), Park Elementary (4.8/5), Strawberry Point Elementary (4.7/5) and Tamalpais Valley Elementary (4.8/5). 2 more schools are listed in the Schools section on this page.
What is the weather like in Alto Sutton Manor?
Alto Sutton Manor, Mill Valley receives 78% of its possible sunshine, 13th of 17 in Mill Valley. Summer days run 54° to 72°F and winter days 44° to 59°F, September is the warmest month and rainfall averages about 35 inches a year.
Is Alto Sutton Manor walkable to shops and restaurants?
Alto Sutton Manor, Mill Valley scores 3.0 out of 5 for nearby merchants and 3.5 out of 5 for public spaces. Its overall amenities score is 3.2 out of 5, 16th of 17 in Mill Valley.
What is Alto Sutton Manor known for?
Alto Sutton Manor, Mill Valley is associated with Highly Accessible, School-Centric and Convenient Location. Its highest-scoring factor is schools (4.7/5).
How does Alto Sutton Manor compare to other Mill Valley neighborhoods?
Alto Sutton Manor ranks 14th of 17 neighborhoods in Mill Valley. It ranks 11th of 17 in Mill Valley for schools (4.7/5) and scores lowest on nearby merchants (3.0/5). The highest-ranked neighborhoods in Mill Valley are Tam Junction and Tennessee Valley.
What are the downsides of living in Alto Sutton Manor?
Alto Sutton Manor, Mill Valley scores lowest on nearby merchants (3.0/5) and curb appeal (3.0/5).
Neighborhood Photos
1 of 4
Top Neighborhoods in Mill Valley, CA
Neighborhood Map
View Full Map
All information provided on this website including but not limited to - school ratings, safety, amenities, user opinions, and property data - is for general informational purposes only. We do not guarantee its reliability, accuracy, or completeness. Users should independently verify information and consult appropriate professionals as needed. By using this website, you agree Houseberry is not responsible for actions, decisions, or consequences arising from reliance on the information provided
houseberry.com - CA DRE# 01847391
Bay East ©2025. CCAR ©2025. bridgeMLS ©2025. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. This information is being provided by the Bay East MLS, or CCAR MLS, or bridgeMLS. The listings presented here may or may not be listed by the Broker/Agent operating this website. This information is intended for the personal use of consumers and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated at August 14, 2026 12:00 AM