Neighborhood Factors

Market Conditions

  • Neighborhood Factors
    Price
    $939k
  • Neighborhood Factors
    Undervalued
    $171k
  • Neighborhood Factors
    Appreciation
    -1%

San Carlos at a Glance

San Carlos is ranked #11 of 110 neighborhoods in San Diego with an overall score of 4.2/5. Its standout factors are safety (4.7/5, 8th of 110 in San Diego) and schools (4.3/5), at a typical home price of $939k, which Houseberry currently rates as undervalued by about $171,000. The trade-off is nearby merchants (2.2/5).

San Carlos Reviews & Questions

Neighborhood Review
Key Words: Lake Murray Reservoir, Trails Eatery, Lake Street Names

Lake Murray gives San Carlos its morning routine. The reservoir sits inside this eastern San Diego neighborhood, and by sunrise the shoreline path is busy with joggers, dog walkers and people carrying tackle boxes down to the water. Carlos Tavares, the developer who also named Clairemont, built San Carlos out of open hill country, and in 1960 streets like Lake Aral Drive were still brand new tract blocks with young lawns. Many streets carry lake names, from Lake Ashmere to Boulder Lake. Ranch houses make up most of the stock, set along streets that bend uphill toward the mountain, and nearly all of it is single-family. Outdoors is the whole point of living here. Lake Murray allows kayaks, canoes and small boats, and anglers fish for bass, catfish, crappie and trout, though swimming and paddleboards are off limits. The lakeside path stops short of a full loop. The Mission Trails Regional Park visitor center is on the north side of San Carlos, and the main Cowles Mountain trailhead, at Navajo Road and Golfcrest Drive, belongs to the Lake Murray neighborhood next door. From there it is roughly 1.4 miles of steady climbing to the top, and mountain bikes are not allowed. Food follows the hikers. The Trails Eatery on Jackson Drive is the post-hike breakfast, with crab cake Benedict and Elvis Cakes, pancakes stuffed with banana and chocolate chips under peanut butter. Cowles Mountain Coffee on Navajo Road pours coffee and serves acai bowls and croissants on a patio, and Pure Press a few doors away makes green smoothies for the trail crowd. Daily errands happen at the Navajo Road and Jackson Drive intersection. Keil's, a family-owned grocery there since 1990, has a deli, a bakery and take-and-bake pizzas and stays open until 10 p.m. The San Carlos Branch Library is down the block on Jackson, and Patrick Henry High School sits inside the neighborhood too. The closest trolley is the Green Line at Grantville, so most trips start in the car. Evenings are quiet, and a night out generally means driving to La Mesa or Mission Valley. Mornings belong to the shoreline and the trail.

See City Review for: San Diego

Top Neighborhoods in San Diego, CA

1st
Map placeholder for Carmel Valley, San Diego - not a photo of the neighborhood
Carmel Valley, San Diego, CA
Overall Score : 4.4
Farms and horse ranches once filled the valley floor that Carmel Valley now cove... See Full Page
2nd
Map placeholder for Del Mar Heights, San Diego - not a photo of the neighborhood
Del Mar Heights, San Diego, CA
Overall Score : 4.4
At the end of Mira Montana Drive, beside Del Mar Heights Elementary, a small cul... See Full Page
3rd
Map placeholder for Pacific Highlands Ranch, San Diego - not a photo of the neighborhood
Pacific Highlands Ranch, San Diego, CA
Overall Score : 4.4
Pacific Highlands Ranch is among the newest parts of San Diego, a stretch of hil... See Full Page

San Carlos Amenities

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Near good merchants

    2.2

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Public Spaces

    3.9

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Curb Appeal

    3.5

Overall Amenities score: 3.4

San Carlos Weather

80%
of possible sunshine
Of all the daylight this spot gets in a year, 80% arrives as sunshine - clouds and fog block the rest.
San Carlos ranks 13th of 110 for sunshine in San Diego, and it out-suns about two thirds of the San Diego area. Its warmest month is August, averaging 83° highs, and it gets about 13 inches of rain a year.
Average daily high and low temperature
85°70°55°40°JFMAMJJASONDAug 83°
Avg highAvg low
Rank in San Diego
13th of 110
Across the San Diego area
64th percentile
Rain per year
13 in
Warmest month
Aug 83° avg high
Summer day
62° → 80°F
Winter day
47° → 67°F
Sunshine and temperature figures are 30-year climate averages for this neighborhood's location.

San Carlos Photos

Schools Serving San Carlos

School NameTypeGradesHouseberry School Score
Green Elementary PrimaryK-5
Marvin Elementary PrimaryK-5
Dailard Elementary PrimaryK-5
Lewis Middle Middle6-8
Pershing Middle Middle6-8
Henry High High9-12

Click links for school listing

info at GreatSchools.org

Houseberry School Score Data

from CA Dept. of Education

Houseberry recommends using these scores as only a starting point, and conducting your own investigation into what schools fit best for your preferences. School boundaries are not guaranteed and may change. It is important to contact the appropriate school district to confirm enrollment eligibility before making any decision to move to a neighborhood.

San Carlos Home Prices

San Carlos FAQs

10 answers

Is San Carlos a good place to live?

San Carlos ranks 11th of 110 neighborhoods in San Diego with an overall Houseberry score of 4.2 out of 5. Its strongest factors are safety (4.7/5) and schools (4.3/5). The trade-off is nearby merchants (2.2/5).

Is San Carlos safe?

San Carlos, San Diego scores 4.7 out of 5 on Houseberry's Safety Score, ranking 8th of 110 neighborhoods in San Diego.

What do homes in San Carlos cost?

The typical home price in San Carlos, San Diego is $939k, compared with $992.15k for San Diego as a whole. Houseberry currently rates it undervalued by about $171,000 against comparable neighborhoods.

Are home prices in San Carlos rising or falling?

The typical home price in San Carlos, San Diego is down about 0.9% over the past 12 months, at $939k. The full 12-month history is charted in the Typical Home Price section on this page.

Which schools serve San Carlos?

Schools serving San Carlos, San Diego include Green Elementary, Marvin Elementary, Dailard Elementary, Lewis Middle and Pershing Middle. 1 more school is listed in the Schools section on this page.

What is the weather like in San Carlos?

San Carlos, San Diego receives 80% of its possible sunshine, 13th of 110 in San Diego. Summer days run 62° to 80°F and winter days 47° to 67°F, August is the warmest month and rainfall averages about 13 inches a year.

Is San Carlos walkable to shops and restaurants?

San Carlos, San Diego scores 2.2 out of 5 for nearby merchants and 3.9 out of 5 for public spaces. Its overall amenities score is 3.4 out of 5, 43rd of 110 in San Diego.

What is San Carlos known for?

San Carlos, San Diego is associated with Lake Murray Reservoir, Trails Eatery and Lake Street Names. Its highest-scoring factors are safety (4.7/5) and schools (4.3/5).

How does San Carlos compare to other San Diego neighborhoods?

San Carlos ranks 11th of 110 neighborhoods in San Diego. It ranks 8th of 110 in San Diego for safety (4.7/5) and scores lowest on nearby merchants (2.2/5). The highest-ranked neighborhoods in San Diego are Carmel Valley and Del Mar Heights.

What are the downsides of living in San Carlos?

San Carlos, San Diego scores lowest on nearby merchants (2.2/5).

Follow this neighborhood for updates
San Carlos Photos
Top Neighborhoods in San Diego, CA
1st
Map placeholder for Carmel Valley, San Diego - not a photo of the neighborhood
Carmel Valley, San Diego, CA
Overall Score : 4.4
Farms and horse ranches once filled the valley floor that Carmel Valley now cove... See Full Page
2nd
Map placeholder for Del Mar Heights, San Diego - not a photo of the neighborhood
Del Mar Heights, San Diego, CA
Overall Score : 4.4
At the end of Mira Montana Drive, beside Del Mar Heights Elementary, a small cul... See Full Page
3rd
Map placeholder for Pacific Highlands Ranch, San Diego - not a photo of the neighborhood
Pacific Highlands Ranch, San Diego, CA
Overall Score : 4.4
Pacific Highlands Ranch is among the newest parts of San Diego, a stretch of hil... See Full Page

San Carlos Map

Loading map...

View Full Map

Contact Houseberry's 2026 Agent Pick for San Carlos
Follow this neighborhood for updates