Safest Neighborhoods in Santa Catalina Island, CA
Santa Catalina Island's highest safety score is 3.3 out of 5, in Santa Catalina Island. 0 ranked Santa Catalina Island neighborhoods score 4 out of 5 or higher for safety.
Learn more about Santa Catalina Island, CA.
Santa Catalina Island, Santa Catalina Island, CA
Keywords: Two Harbors, Trans-Catalina Trail, Island Conservancy
Outside Avalon, Santa Catalina Island is less a conventional neighborhood than a vast protected landscape with one tiny village at its western end. The Catalina Island Conservancy manages most of the island, leaving canyons, ridges and coves open and wonderfully undeveloped. ... See Full Page
Scores updated October 2026
Safest Neighborhoods
Loading map...
View Full Map
Santa Catalina Island safety: your questions, answered
What are the safest neighborhoods in Santa Catalina Island?
Santa Catalina Island has the highest safety score in Santa Catalina Island, at 3.3 out of 5.
Is Santa Catalina Island safe?
Houseberry scores Santa Catalina Island's 1 ranked neighborhood from 3.3 to 3.3 out of 5 for safety. No Santa Catalina Island neighborhood scores 4.0 out of 5 or higher for safety.
What do homes cost in Santa Catalina Island's top safety-rated neighborhoods?
Santa Catalina Island, which has the highest safety score in Santa Catalina Island with a price on record, has a typical home price of $970,000.
More Santa Catalina Island rankings
- Best neighborhoods in Santa Catalina Island
- Best neighborhoods for schools in Santa Catalina Island
- Best neighborhoods for amenities in Santa Catalina Island
- Most affordable neighborhoods in Santa Catalina Island
- Best-value neighborhoods in Santa Catalina Island
- Fastest-appreciating neighborhoods in Santa Catalina Island