Best-Value Neighborhoods in Arcadia, CA

San FranciscoPeninsulaSilicon ValleyEast BayMarin

Overall Score

Overall Score

School

School

Safety

Safety

Amenities

Amenities

Price

Price

Value

Value

Appreciation

Appreciation

None of the 9 ranked Arcadia neighborhoods with a value figure is priced below its expected value.

Houseberry scores 9 Arcadia neighborhoods on schools, safety, amenities, price, value and appreciation. Overall scores in Arcadia run from 3.8 to 4.3 out of 5, and 7 score 4 out of 5 or higher. Median home prices range from $924,000 in West Arcadia to $3,746,000 in Upper Rancho across 9 priced neighborhoods.

Learn more about Arcadia, CA.

1st
Arcadia Highlands, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Arcadia Highlands, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.3/5
SCHOOL4.5/5
SAFETY4.0/5
AMENITIES0.8/5
PRICE$1,511,000
APPRECIATION0.70 %
VALUE-
2nd
Santa Anita Oaks, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Santa Anita Oaks, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.3/5
SCHOOL4.5/5
SAFETY4.4/5
AMENITIES0.4/5
PRICE$3,124,000
APPRECIATION0.60 %
VALUE-
3rd
Upper Rancho, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Upper Rancho, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.3/5
SCHOOL4.4/5
SAFETY4.3/5
AMENITIES0.3/5
PRICE$3,746,000
APPRECIATION0.30 %
VALUE-
4th
Baldwin Stocker, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Baldwin Stocker, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.2/5
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY4.2/5
AMENITIES0.4/5
PRICE$2,351,000
APPRECIATION0.90 %
VALUE-
5th
Peacock Village, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Peacock Village, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.2/5
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY4.2/5
AMENITIES0.4/5
PRICE$2,206,000
APPRECIATION0.90 %
VALUE-
6th
Santa Anita Village, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Santa Anita Village, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.0/5
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY3.9/5
AMENITIES0.8/5
PRICE$1,187,000
APPRECIATION0.90 %
VALUE-
7th
West Arcadia, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

West Arcadia, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.0/5
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY3.7/5
AMENITIES0.9/5
PRICE$924,000
APPRECIATION0.90 %
VALUE-
8th
Lower Rancho, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Lower Rancho, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 3.9/5
SCHOOL4.4/5
SAFETY3.5/5
AMENITIES0.6/5
PRICE$1,623,000
APPRECIATION0.70 %
VALUE-
9th
South Arcadia, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

South Arcadia, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 3.8/5
SCHOOL3.8/5
SAFETY4.1/5
AMENITIES0.5/5
PRICE$1,719,000
APPRECIATION0.20 %
VALUE-

Scores updated September 2026

Best-Value Neighborhoods

Loading map...

View Full Map

Arcadia home value: your questions, answered

How many Arcadia neighborhoods are priced below their expected value?

0 of 9 ranked Arcadia neighborhoods with a value figure are priced below expected value, and 0 are priced above it.

More Arcadia rankings

Zoom out