Best-Value Neighborhoods in Arcadia, CA

None of the 9 ranked Arcadia neighborhoods with a value figure is priced below its expected value.

Houseberry scores 9 Arcadia neighborhoods on schools, safety, amenities, price, value and appreciation. Overall scores in Arcadia run from 3.5 to 4.2 out of 5, and 3 score 4 out of 5 or higher. Typical home prices range from $924,000 in West Arcadia to $3,746,000 in Upper Rancho across 9 priced neighborhoods.

Learn more about Arcadia, CA.

1st
Upper Rancho, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Upper Rancho, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.2/5
SCHOOL4.4/5
SAFETY4.3/5
AMENITIES3.7/5
PRICE$3,746,000
APPRECIATION0.30 %
VALUE-

Keywords: Arboretum Neighbor, Rancho Estates, Peafowl Streets

Upper Rancho is the Arcadia neighborhood right beside the Los Angeles County Arboretum, and the peafowl that wander out of the gardens treat its lawns as their own. The name comes from Lucky Baldwin's Rancho Santa Anita, and the estate-scale lots still carry some of that ranch-era sense of room. ... See Full Page

2nd
Arcadia Highlands, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Arcadia Highlands, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.1/5
SCHOOL4.5/5
SAFETY4.0/5
AMENITIES4.2/5
PRICE$1,511,000
APPRECIATION0.70 %
VALUE-

Keywords: Wilderness Park, Hillside Streets, Goldstein's Bagels

Arcadia Highlands climbs from the busy flats of Arcadia up toward the San Gabriel Mountains, and the higher you go, the quieter and steeper it gets. ... See Full Page

3rd
Santa Anita Oaks, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Santa Anita Oaks, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 4.1/5
SCHOOL4.5/5
SAFETY4.4/5
AMENITIES3.6/5
PRICE$3,124,000
APPRECIATION0.60 %
VALUE-

Keywords: Estate Lots, 1940s Custom Homes, Mountain Backdrop

Santa Anita Oaks sits at the foot of the San Gabriel Mountains in Arcadia, north of the 210, where wide streets run under old oaks and houses sit far back from the curb. Most of it was built out in the 1940s, and it reads more like a string of private estates than a subdivision. ... See Full Page

4th
Baldwin Stocker, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Baldwin Stocker, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 3.9/5
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY4.2/5
AMENITIES3.1/5
PRICE$2,351,000
APPRECIATION0.90 %
VALUE-

Keywords: Chicken Pie Shop, South Baldwin Avenue, Mid-Century Homes

Baldwin Stocker is the quiet residential pocket of southwest Arcadia around the Baldwin Avenue and Duarte Road area, named for the elementary school and small park at its center. It sits just south of the city's busiest food corridor, close enough to walk for dinner but set back on residential streets. ... See Full Page

5th
Peacock Village, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Peacock Village, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 3.9/5
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY4.2/5
AMENITIES3.4/5
PRICE$2,206,000
APPRECIATION0.90 %
VALUE-

Keywords: Hugo Reid Park, Curving Streets, Free-Roaming Peafowl

Peacock Village takes its name from the birds that stroll its streets, peafowl drifting over from the Los Angeles County Arboretum into front yards across this corner of west Arcadia. The neighborhood runs between Michillinda and Baldwin avenues, from Huntington Drive up to Colorado Street, and its curving layout feels different from the grid around it. ... See Full Page

6th
Lower Rancho, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

Lower Rancho, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 3.8/5
SCHOOL4.4/5
SAFETY3.5/5
AMENITIES3.9/5
PRICE$1,623,000
APPRECIATION0.70 %
VALUE-

Keywords: Santa Anita Park, LA County Arboretum, Arcadia County Park

Lower Rancho holds the two places that put Arcadia on the map, Santa Anita Park and the Los Angeles County Arboretum, and the homes around them share a backdrop of Art Deco grandstands, old gardens and the San Gabriel Mountains. ... See Full Page

7th
Santa Anita Village, Arcadia, CA neighborhood
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY3.9/5
AMENITIES3.6/5
PRICE$1,187,000
APPRECIATION0.90 %
VALUE-

Keywords: H Mart Plaza, Postwar Ranch Homes, Fika Fika Coffee

Santa Anita Village is a postwar neighborhood on Arcadia's west side, south of Huntington Drive near Michillinda Avenue, and its main street corner has turned into one of the city's handiest little food stops. The houses behind it are low, steady and mid-century, which makes the busy plaza feel like a small downtown for the blocks around it. ... See Full Page

8th
West Arcadia, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

West Arcadia, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 3.8/5
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY3.7/5
AMENITIES3.3/5
PRICE$924,000
APPRECIATION0.90 %
VALUE-

Keywords: Westfield Santa Anita, Duarte Road Dining, Dumpling Houses

West Arcadia is where the city eats. The stretch of Baldwin Avenue running south from Westfield Santa Anita, crossed by Duarte Road and Naomi Avenue, holds one of the densest runs of Taiwanese, Cantonese, Sichuan and Japanese restaurants in the San Gabriel Valley, and the Arcadia neighborhood around it lives with that energy every day. ... See Full Page

9th
South Arcadia, Arcadia, CA neighborhood

South Arcadia, Arcadia, CA

Overall Score : 3.5/5
SCHOOL3.8/5
SAFETY4.1/5
AMENITIES3.2/5
PRICE$1,719,000
APPRECIATION0.20 %
VALUE-

Keywords: Live Oak Avenue, Arcadia Golf Course, Peck Road Park

South Arcadia is the city's working, everyday side, where Live Oak Avenue lines up family restaurants, donut shops and supermarkets, and a public golf course and bike paths fill the southern edge. It feels more lived-in and less polished than north Arcadia, with errands, dinner and exercise all close together. ... See Full Page

Scores updated October 2026

Best-Value Neighborhoods

Loading map...

View Full Map