Best-Value Neighborhoods in Benicia, CA

Eastside sits furthest below its expected value of any ranked Benicia neighborhood, at $49k. 2 of 3 ranked neighborhoods with a value figure are priced below expected value. Southampton is next at $3k.

Houseberry scores 3 Benicia neighborhoods on schools, safety, amenities, price, value and appreciation. Overall scores in Benicia run from 4.1 to 4.3 out of 5, and 3 score 4 out of 5 or higher. Typical home prices range from $633,000 in Eastside to $800,000 in Southampton across 3 priced neighborhoods. Across the five nearest cities the average overall score is 2.6 out of 5, against 4.2 in Benicia.

Learn more about Benicia, CA.

1st
Eastside, Benicia, CA neighborhood

Eastside, Benicia, CA

Overall Score : 4.1/5
SCHOOL3.9/5
SAFETY4.5/5
AMENITIES1.8/5
PRICE$633,000
APPRECIATION-1.80 %
VALUE$49kUndervalued
2nd
Southampton, Benicia, CA neighborhood

Southampton, Benicia, CA

Overall Score : 4.3/5
SCHOOL3.9/5
SAFETY5.0/5
AMENITIES0.8/5
PRICE$800,000
APPRECIATION-1.30 %
VALUE$3kUndervalued
3rd
West Side, Benicia, CA neighborhood

West Side, Benicia, CA

Overall Score : 4.1/5
SCHOOL3.9/5
SAFETY4.5/5
AMENITIES2/5
PRICE$797,000
APPRECIATION1.50 %
VALUE$82kOvervalued

Scores updated November 2026

Best-Value Neighborhoods

Loading map...

View Full Map

Benicia home value: your questions, answered

Which Benicia neighborhoods offer the best value for the price?

2 Benicia neighborhoods are priced below expected value. The largest gaps are Eastside ($49k) and Southampton ($3k).

Which Benicia neighborhoods combine a below-expected price with a high overall score?

2 Benicia neighborhoods priced below expected value also score 4 out of 5 or higher overall: Eastside (4.1 out of 5, $49k below) and Southampton (4.3 out of 5, $3k below).

Which Benicia neighborhoods are priced above their expected value?

1 Benicia neighborhood is priced above expected value. The largest gaps are West Side ($82k).

What do homes cost in Benicia's best-value neighborhoods?

The typical home price across the 2 Benicia neighborhoods priced below expected value is $716,500. Eastside, with the largest gap, has a typical home price of $633,000.

How many Benicia neighborhoods are priced below their expected value?

2 of 3 ranked Benicia neighborhoods with a value figure are priced below expected value, and 1 is priced above it.

How does Benicia compare with nearby cities on home value?

67% of ranked Benicia neighborhoods are priced below expected value. The nearest cities are Crockett 0%, Rodeo 100%, Martinez 40%, Vallejo 0% and Hercules 0%.