Best-Value Neighborhoods in Carnelian Bay, CA

None of the 2 ranked Carnelian Bay neighborhoods with a value figure is priced below its expected value.

Houseberry scores 2 Carnelian Bay neighborhoods on schools, safety, amenities, price, value and appreciation. Overall scores in Carnelian Bay run from 3.8 to 3.9 out of 5, and 0 score 4 out of 5 or higher. Median home prices range from $840,000 in Agate Bay to $860,000 in Carnelian Bay across 2 priced neighborhoods.

Learn more about Carnelian Bay, CA.

1st
Carnelian Bay, Carnelian Bay, CA neighborhood
SCHOOL3.6/5
SAFETY4.5/5
AMENITIES3/5
PRICE$860,000
APPRECIATION-1.20 %
VALUE-

Carnelian Bay is the north shore's wooden-boat town, and its history is delightfully odd. It was originally spelled Cornelian, for the translucent red and yellow stones that littered the beach, until the 1880s. Before that, in 1871, Dr. George Bourne opened a health spa here and got so carried away he petitioned to rename the whole lake Sanatoria. The Flick brothers, three Illinois men all born on Christmas Day, bought his holdings in the 1890s and left their name on Flick Point. ... See Full Page

2nd
Agate Bay, Carnelian Bay, CA neighborhood

Agate Bay, Carnelian Bay, CA

Overall Score : 3.8/5
SCHOOL3.6/5
SAFETY4.4/5
AMENITIES2.8/5
PRICE$840,000
APPRECIATION-1.20 %
VALUE-

Agate Bay is the quiet residential bay wedged between busier neighbors, and it shares its name with the beach pebbles, agate being the sister stone to the carnelian that named Carnelian Bay next door. Most of the commercial life, the restaurants and the boat company, clusters just west at the Carnelian line, which leaves Agate Bay itself as mostly homes, small-to-mid lots and cabin and mid-century stock climbing the slope from the water. ... See Full Page

Scores updated September 2026

Best-Value Neighborhoods

Loading map...

View Full Map

Carnelian Bay home value: your questions, answered

How many Carnelian Bay neighborhoods are priced below their expected value?

0 of 2 ranked Carnelian Bay neighborhoods with a value figure are priced below expected value, and 0 are priced above it.