Aragon ranks first of 23 ranked San Mateo neighborhoods on overall score, at 4.4 out of 5. Baywood is next at 4.3 out of 5. 4 San Mateo neighborhoods score 4 out of 5 or higher overall.
Houseberry scores 23 San Mateo neighborhoods on schools, safety, amenities, price, value and appreciation. Overall scores in San Mateo run from 2.6 to 4.4 out of 5, and 4 score 4 out of 5 or higher. Median home prices range from $1,319,960 in South Shoreview to $4,654,990 in San Mateo Park across 23 priced neighborhoods. Across the five nearest cities the average overall score is 3.9 out of 5, against 3.5 in San Mateo.
Learn more about San Mateo, CA.

(2) City data used
Keywords: Historical Elegance, Active Community Life, Prestigious Atmosphere
Aragon stands out in San Mateo for its well-preserved historical homes. The streets are a gallery of early 20th-century architecture, where the detailed Spanish Revival and Tudor styles are the main attractions. It's a residential gallery that showcases the care homeowners put into their properties. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Upscale and Welcoming, Diverse Architecture, Strong Community
Baywood stands out in San Mateo with its stately homes and well-kept gardens, radiating a vibe that's both welcoming and upscale. This neighborhood is for those who appreciate an environment where community pride is as evident in the landscapes as it is in the warm greetings from neighbors. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Balance, Waterfront Access, Close to Shopping
Mariner's Isle is unique in Foster City in that it offers abundant housing, but also office and shopping, all within walking distance. Most of the homes are attached duplexes in this neighborhood, along with some large apartment complexes. Many homes are waterfront, and some belong to the Mariner’s Greens Homeowners association which offers a clubhouse and pool. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Panoramic views, Spacious privacy, Nature-integrated living
Laurelwood & Sugarloaf offers a scenic retreat within the city of San Mateo. Perched with a view, this neighborhood boasts the kind of vistas that make even a simple evening stroll a moment to remember. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Quiet Streets, Generous Lot Sizes, Community-Centered
Baywood Park is a well-established San Mateo neighborhood known for its quiet streets and friendly atmosphere. The housing here showcases a wide range, from 1950s originals to new-builds, offering potential residents a choice between classic charm and modern comfort. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Suburban Charm, Community-Centric, Recreational Luxury
San Mateo Terrace, often regarded as the western side of Beresford Park, offers a blend of suburban charm and community-centric living. This neighborhood, characterized by its serene streets and friendly atmosphere, stands out as a preferred destination for families and individuals alike who seek a balanced lifestyle. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Secluded tranquility, Midcentury Charm, Community-centered living
Western Hills in San Mateo, CA, is a picturesque neighborhood that’s as charming as it is quietly upscale. It’s a little pocket where the pace slows, the trees sway a little more leisurely, and the views can be just breathtaking. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Lively and Inviting, Diverse Housing, Active Parks
Parkside in San Mateo presents itself as a lively and inviting neighborhood where the community pulse is always felt. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Suburban charm, Community Engagement, Eichler homes
San Mateo Village in San Mateo, CA, is a slice of suburban charm within the larger urban context, known for its family-friendly atmosphere and well-established community feel. If you're looking for a neighborhood that strikes a balance between accessibility to city amenities and the allure of a close-knit community, this is the place. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Tree-lined Streets, Mid-century Charm, Nature-infused Living
Westwood Knolls sits just West of El Camino Real, offering close access to restaurants and amenities, while offering a peaceful suburban vibe. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Community warmth, Architectural diversity, Walk to Outdoor Paradise
San Mateo Knolls features an eclectic mix of housing, where mid-century homes sit comfortably alongside newer constructions. It's the kind of place where each house has its own character, often accompanied by mature trees that serve as quiet sentinels of the neighborhood's long-standing roots. The architectural diversity here offers a snapshot of the area's growth over the decades, from the simple elegance of older homes to the sleek lines of new developments. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Prestigious Suburb, Timeless Elegance, Natural Serenity
San Mateo Park is a lush, residential haven, boasting winding streets lined with mature trees and a mix of architectural styles that give the area a timeless elegance. This is widely known as San Mateo’s most prestigious neighborhood, and it shows. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Cozy Suburban Feel, Community Spirit, Neighborly Ties
Homestead offers a cozy, suburban feel with a strong sense of community at its core. It's a pocket of San Mateo that prides itself on friendly faces and neighborly spirit, making it an attractive place for those looking to establish roots in a tight-knit environment. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Historic Charm, Suburban Convenience, Central Park Oasis
Hayward Park exudes a sense of historic charm mingled with suburban convenience. This neighborhood feels like a page out of history, where the architectural grandeur of yesteryears is still on full display, blending seamlessly with modern comforts. A huge draw is its location: situated within walking distance of downtown San Mateo, it offers the conveniences of being next to one of the largest concentrations of restaurants and shops on the peninsula. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Coastal Proximity, Modest Homes, Practical Spirit
South Shoreview in San Mateo is where the suburban layout meets the benefits of coastal proximity. It's a neighborhood with a practical spirit, appealing to those who appreciate straightforward, no-fuss living with the bonus of a brisk bay breeze. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Waterfront Access, Family-Friendly, Outdoor Recreation
North Shoreview is a scenic and family-friendly neighborhood in San Mateo, known for its proximity to the Bay and its abundance of outdoor recreational opportunities. Nestled between the San Francisco Bay and the bustling downtown area, this neighborhood offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and suburban convenience. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Mid-Century Modern Charm, Community-Focused, Architectural Heritage
San Mateo Highlands is a distinctive enclave that exudes a certain mid-century modern charisma, perched above the city to afford its residents not just homes, but vistas. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Waterfront Lifestyle, Scenic Lagoon Views, Recreational Hub
Lakeshore in San Mateo is a neighborhood that's all about embracing the waterfront lifestyle. It stands out with its scenic lagoon views, which many of the apartments here are privileged to have. It's a slice of the Bay Area where the water's edge plays a central role in the daily life of the community. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Neighborly Atmosphere, 1950s Charm, Community Parks
Sunnybrae presents a refreshing slice of suburban life with an inviting, friendly atmosphere. It's like a small-town scene nestled within the larger urban context, where neighbors know each other by name and the streets are lined with a mix of mature trees and well-tended gardens. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Tight-knit community, Post-WWII Ranch Houses, Community events
Welcome to Fiesta Gardens, a neighborhood in San Mateo that lives up to its celebratory name with a tight-knit community vibe that’s hard to find elsewhere. It’s the kind of place where neighbors know each other by name and the streets are lined with well-kept homes that exhibit a suburban charm. ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Suburban Dream, Neighborly Pride, Mid-Century Charm
If you're on the hunt for a neighborhood that captures the essence of San Mateo's charm, Beresford Manor is a pocket where the suburban dream is still going strong. It's like that friend who's always got a smile and a story to tell – familiar, warm, and welcoming. ... See Full Page

Keywords: Affordable, Urban Grid, Transit-Accessible
North Central, San Mateo, CA ... See Full Page

(2) City data used
Keywords: Dynamic Urban Hub, Architectural Diversity, Central Park Proximity
Downtown San Mateo offers an energetic and vibrant community in the heart of the Peninsula. It’s a dynamic mix of urban convenience and small-town charm, where the streets buzz with activity from sunrise to well past sunset. If you're seeking the pulse of the city intertwined with a sense of close-knit community, this is your ground zero. ... See Full Page
Scores updated August 2026
Loading map...
View Full Map
Aragon has the highest overall score in San Mateo, at 4.4 out of 5. The next highest overall scores in San Mateo are Baywood (4.3 out of 5) and Mariner's Isle (4.0 out of 5).
Houseberry's highest-scored San Mateo neighborhoods are Aragon (4.4 out of 5), Baywood (4.3 out of 5) and Mariner's Isle (4.0 out of 5), out of 23 ranked on safety, schools, amenities and value.
5 San Mateo neighborhoods score 3.5 out of 5 or higher for schools, safety and amenities: Aragon, Baywood, Mariner's Isle and Laurelwood & Sugarloaf. Aragon has the highest combined total in San Mateo, at 4.1 out of 5 for schools, 4.9 out of 5 for safety and 4.0 out of 5 for amenities.
Across the top 5 San Mateo neighborhoods by overall score, the median home price is $2,806,140. Prices among those top 5 San Mateo neighborhoods run from $1,414,010 in Mariner's Isle to $3,415,170 in Baywood.
Mariner's Isle has the lowest median home price, $1,414,010, among San Mateo neighborhoods scoring 3.9 out of 5 or higher for overall score and priced below the San Mateo median of $2,336,530; Mariner's Isle scores 4.0 out of 5 for overall score.
Houseberry ranks 23 neighborhoods in San Mateo. 4 San Mateo neighborhoods score 4 out of 5 or higher overall.
San Mateo neighborhoods average 3.5 out of 5 overall. The nearest cities average Hillsborough 4.2, Belmont 4.1, Foster City 3.5, Burlingame 4.0 and San Carlos 3.7.
Hillsborough · Belmont · Foster City · Burlingame · San Carlos