Best-Value Neighborhoods in Foster City, CA

Bay Vista sits furthest below its expected value of any ranked Foster City neighborhood, at $12k. 1 of 1 ranked neighborhood with a value figure are priced below expected value.

Houseberry scores 11 Foster City neighborhoods on schools, safety, amenities, price, value and appreciation. Overall scores in Foster City run from 2.6 to 4.3 out of 5, and 1 scores 4 out of 5 or higher. Median home prices range from $1,900,000 in The Islands to $2,805,640 in Harbor Side across 10 priced neighborhoods. Across the five nearest cities the average overall score is 3.8 out of 5, against 3.5 in Foster City.

Learn more about Foster City, CA.

1st
The Islands, Foster City, CA neighborhood

The Islands, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.9/5
SCHOOL4.4/5
SAFETY3.3/5
AMENITIES3.8/5
PRICE$1,900,000
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Condo Living, New Elementary, Catamaran Park

The Islands is one of Foster City's smallest neighborhoods, just a handful of blocks tucked between Shell Boulevard and the water. There are single family waterfront homes on the western side, but the bulk of the neighborhood is condos and townhomes, which makes it one of the more accessible ways to get a Foster City address. ... See Full Page

2nd
Sea Colony, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Sea Colony, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.9/5
SCHOOL4.5/5
SAFETY3.4/5
AMENITIES3.8/5
PRICE$2,542,870
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Sea Cloud Fields, Island Lanes, Park Density

Sea Colony is the biggest neighborhood in Foster City and the one most completely organized around the water. It occupies the southern end of the city, where the lagoon system and Belmont Slough meet, and the design pushes the water into almost every block. ... See Full Page

3rd
Vintage Park, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Vintage Park, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 2.6/5
SCHOOL3.5/5
SAFETY1.8/5
AMENITIES2.8/5
PRICE$2,725,000
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Gilead Campus, Golf Center, Workplace District

You probably will not live in Vintage Park, but there is a decent chance you will work here, and a very good chance you will end up here anyway. This is Foster City's jobs district, sitting at the northwest corner of the city. ... See Full Page

4th
Dolphin Bay, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Dolphin Bay, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 4.3/5
SCHOOL4.5/5
SAFETY4.1/5
AMENITIES4/5
PRICE$2,562,740
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Waterside Boardwalk, Park Anchored, Quick Commute

Dolphin Bay is Foster City's answer to balance. Primarily single family homes, some still carrying their original 1970s bones, others taken down to the studs and rebuilt into something you would not guess from the street. Like most of the city, a good number of homes back directly onto the water with dock access. ... See Full Page

5th
Bay Vista, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Bay Vista, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.4/5
SCHOOL4.2/5
SAFETY2.5/5
AMENITIES3.5/5
PRICE$2,138,210
APPRECIATION-12.81 %
VALUE$12kUndervalued

Keywords: Eichler Architecture, Levee Trail, Lagoon Beach

Bay Vista is the part of Foster City that architecture people come looking for. Those flat-roofed houses are Eichlers, built between 1963 and 1968 when the town was brand new, and this is the largest tract of them in the city. They sit intermixed with other contemporary homes on the streets and cul-de-sacs between Gull Avenue and Beach Park Boulevard. Post-and-beam construction, glass walls, atriums, and the whole indoor-outdoor idea, right at the eastern edge of Foster City between the lagoon and San Francisco Bay. ... See Full Page

6th
Metro Center, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Metro Center, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.4/5
SCHOOL4.1/5
SAFETY2.6/5
AMENITIES3.4/5
PRICE$2,154,710(1)
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(1) Limited data(2) City data used

Keywords: Office Towers, Big Box Retail, No Single Family

Metro Center is Foster City's engine room, and it makes no attempt to be charming about it. This is where the office towers are, where the big-box shopping is, and where a large share of the city's daytime population actually shows up. ... See Full Page

7th
Carmel Village, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Carmel Village, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.6/5
SCHOOL4.2/5
SAFETY2.9/5
AMENITIES4.1/5
PRICE$2,181,010
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Boat Dock Homes, Island Streets, Waterfront Premium

Carmel Village is where Foster City goes a bit more upscale. It runs between the lagoon and the Bay, and your odds of ending up waterfront, or at least with a real view, are better here than in most of the city. ... See Full Page

8th
Treasure Isle, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Treasure Isle, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.5/5
SCHOOL4.5/5
SAFETY2.5/5
AMENITIES3.8/5
PRICE$2,071,620
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Civic Center, Central Lake, Live Work Shop

Treasure Isle sits at the dead center of Foster City and functions as its downtown, to the extent that a planned lagoon city has one. Residential, retail, and office all share the same boundary, and it is one of the very few neighborhoods here where living, working, and shopping within walking distance is actually plausible rather than aspirational. ... See Full Page

9th
Marina Point, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Marina Point, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.3/5
SCHOOL4.2/5
SAFETY2.1/5
AMENITIES3.9/5
PRICE$2,650,040
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Inland Living, Court Layout, Walkable Groceries

Marina Point is the Foster City neighborhood that is least about the water, which in this city is almost a personality. Aside from a couple of apartment complexes and a handful of homes, life here happens inland, and the neighborhood is better for it in ways people do not expect. ... See Full Page

10th
Harbor Side, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Harbor Side, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.9/5
SCHOOL4.3/5
SAFETY3.4/5
AMENITIES3.7/5
PRICE$2,805,640
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Duffy Boat Culture, Waterfront Density, Purely Residential

Street by street, Harbor Side puts more people on the water than almost any other neighborhood in Foster City. You will find a mix here: single family homes, townhouses, and condos, which is unusual for a neighborhood this waterfront-heavy and one reason it is a more attainable way into lagoon living than the isles in Carmel Village. ... See Full Page

11th
Isle Cove, Foster City, CA neighborhood

Isle Cove, Foster City, CA

Overall Score : 3.2/5
SCHOOL4.5/5
SAFETY1.8/5
AMENITIES3.6/5
PRICE$2,700,000
APPRECIATION0.09 %(2)
VALUE$15k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Cove Waterways, Private Docks, Sports Fields

Isle Cove is built around coves and waterways rather than a straight lagoon frontage, and the effect is that the whole neighborhood feels a little like its own island. Streets curl in on themselves, the water keeps reappearing where you did not expect it, and there is a real sense of being tucked in. ... See Full Page

Scores updated August 2026

Best-Value Neighborhoods

Loading map...

View Full Map

Foster City home value: your questions, answered

Which Foster City neighborhoods offer the best value for the price?

1 Foster City neighborhood is priced below expected value. The largest gaps are Bay Vista ($12k).

What do homes cost in Foster City's best-value neighborhoods?

The median home price across the 1 Foster City neighborhood priced below expected value is $2,138,210. Bay Vista, with the largest gap, has a median home price of $2,138,210.

How many Foster City neighborhoods are priced below their expected value?

1 of 1 ranked Foster City neighborhood with a value figure is priced below expected value, and 0 are priced above it.

How does Foster City compare with nearby cities on home value?

100% of ranked Foster City neighborhoods are priced below expected value. The nearest cities are San Mateo 96%, Belmont 89%, San Carlos 14%, Hillsborough 0% and Redwood City 33%.