Best-Value Neighborhoods in Gilroy, CA

Lions Creek sits furthest below its expected value of any ranked Gilroy neighborhood, at $36k. 1 of 1 ranked neighborhood with a value figure are priced below expected value.

Houseberry scores 11 Gilroy neighborhoods on schools, safety, amenities, price, value and appreciation. Overall scores in Gilroy run from 2.1 to 3.5 out of 5, and 0 score 4 out of 5 or higher. Median home prices range from $887,142 in Las Animas to $1,563,820 in Eagle Ridge across 11 priced neighborhoods. Across the five nearest cities the average overall score is 3.6 out of 5, against 2.7 in Gilroy.

Learn more about Gilroy, CA.

1st
Harvest Park, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Harvest Park, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 2.5/5
SCHOOL2.8/5
SAFETY2.7/5
AMENITIES2.6/5
PRICE$1,000,590
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Northside Subdivisions, Newer Construction, Day Road

Harvest Park sits at the northern edge of Gilroy, a newer residential tract bounded by Day Road up top and Kern Avenue at the bottom, with Farrell Avenue and Woodcreek Way framing the sides. The homes are part of the wave of single-family subdivisions that filled in north Gilroy, so the streetscape is clean and consistent in a way the older central neighborhoods aren't. ... See Full Page

2nd
Mesa Ranch, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Mesa Ranch, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 2.3/5
SCHOOL2.6/5
SAFETY2.4/5
AMENITIES2.2/5
PRICE$990,186
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: South Gilroy, Semi-Rural Edge, Open Foothills

Mesa Ranch sits at the far southern end of Gilroy, where the city's street grid starts giving way to open foothills. Mesa Road wraps its northern and western sides and Castro Valley Road runs along the bottom, with Santa Teresa Boulevard forming the eastern edge. The setting is semi-rural, with more space and sky than you get in the central neighborhoods. ... See Full Page

3rd
Mesa Ridge, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Mesa Ridge, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 2.6/5
SCHOOL2.6/5
SAFETY2.4/5
AMENITIES2.6/5
PRICE$1,499,650
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Hillside Views, Elevated Lots, Premium Homes

Mesa Ridge is a small hillside enclave on Gilroy's south side, built up the slope with Michael Bo Lane threading through it and open hills rising behind. The homes are newer and larger, and the prices reflect both the construction and the elevated lots, which is why this pocket runs well above the south-side average. ... See Full Page

4th
Eagle Ridge, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Eagle Ridge, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 2.9/5
SCHOOL2.6/5
SAFETY3.0/5
AMENITIES3.6/5
PRICE$1,563,820
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Gated Golf, Hillside Estates, Mediterranean Homes

Eagle Ridge is Gilroy's marquee address, a gated, master-planned community spread across the rolling hills southwest of Santa Teresa Boulevard and wrapped around the Eagle Ridge Golf Club at its center. The Mediterranean-style homes date to the early 2000s and sit on generous lots along the fairways, with a clubhouse, pool, and tennis behind the gate and a guard out front. ... See Full Page

5th
Las Animas, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Las Animas, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 2.8/5
SCHOOL3.0/5
SAFETY2.9/5
AMENITIES3/5
PRICE$887,142
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Park Adjacent, Veterans Park, Established Streets

Las Animas is a north-central neighborhood whose best feature is right at its doorstep: Las Animas Veterans Park, the 23-acre community park along Mantelli Drive with ball fields, tennis and basketball courts, a skate facility, and walking paths that stay lit for night play. For a mid-priced part of Gilroy, that's a real amenity to have on the western edge. ... See Full Page

6th
Lions Creek, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Lions Creek, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 3.5/5
SCHOOL3.1/5
SAFETY4.0/5
AMENITIES3.4/5
PRICE$1,101,890
APPRECIATION-8.61 %
VALUE$36kUndervalued

Keywords: Quiet Westside, Trail Access, Hillside Setting

Lions Creek is one of the quieter, safer pockets on Gilroy's west side, set near the base of the Hecker Pass corridor with Valley Oaks Drive along its western flank and Hecker Pass Road running the south edge. It's close to the Uvas Creek levee trail, the paved path locals just call the Levee, which runs for miles toward Christmas Hill Park and the Hecker Pass foothills. ... See Full Page

7th
Sunrise Park, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Sunrise Park, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 3.5/5
SCHOOL2.9/5
SAFETY4.4/5
AMENITIES3.3/5
PRICE$1,248,780
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Quiet Northwest, Neighborhood Park, Calm Streets

Sunrise Park is a calm residential neighborhood in northwest Gilroy, and the park it's named for sits right inside it, giving the streets a green center to orient around. It's one of the most settled-feeling parts of the city, the kind of quiet where the neighborhood park is the main event and through-traffic is somebody else's problem. ... See Full Page

8th
Miller Avenue, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Miller Avenue, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 2.3/5
SCHOOL2.6/5
SAFETY1.9/5
AMENITIES2.6/5
PRICE$1,001,630
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Central Corridor, Christmas Hill Nearby, Walkable Errands

Miller Avenue covers the residential blocks just west of downtown Gilroy, framed by Wren Avenue on the west and Carmel Street on the east, with the Miller Avenue corridor running through. It's a central, older part of the city, which means you're close to the action and to everyday errands in a way the edge neighborhoods aren't. ... See Full Page

9th
Crestwood, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Crestwood, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 2.7/5
SCHOOL3.0/5
SAFETY2.7/5
AMENITIES3/5
PRICE$944,666
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Westside Residential, Santa Teresa Corridor, Everyday Value

Crestwood is one of the more down-to-earth pockets of west Gilroy, a grid of established residential streets tucked against Santa Teresa Boulevard on its south and west edges, with Ramona Way closing it off to the north. The homes here are practical rather than showy, and prices tend to run lower than the newer hillside tracts a few minutes south and west. ... See Full Page

10th
Downtown Gilroy, Gilroy, CA neighborhood

Downtown Gilroy, Gilroy, CA

Overall Score : 2.1/5
SCHOOL2.3/5
SAFETY1.7/5
AMENITIES2.8/5
PRICE$935,130
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Walkable Core, Caltrain Access, Monterey Street

Downtown Gilroy is the part of the city that actually works as a downtown, built around Monterey Street and its row of restaurants, bars, and storefronts, with Gourmet Alley tucked in behind. The Gilroy Caltrain station sits right inside the district, which makes this the one neighborhood where you can realistically get by without leaning on a car for everything. ... See Full Page

11th
Ventana at Los Arroyos, Gilroy, CA neighborhood
SCHOOL3.0/5
SAFETY2.7/5
AMENITIES3/5
PRICE$1,197,570
APPRECIATION-2.05 %(2)
VALUE$62k(2)Undervalued

(2) City data used

Keywords: Planned Community, Newer Homes, Northwest Setting

Ventana at Los Arroyos is a newer planned community in northwest Gilroy, a self-contained subdivision of recent-vintage homes laid out around streets like Summerhill Circle and Daffodil Place. Everything here is built to the same plan and era, so the streetscape is uniform, clean, and clearly newer than the older central neighborhoods. ... See Full Page

Scores updated August 2026

Best-Value Neighborhoods

Loading map...

View Full Map

Gilroy home value: your questions, answered

Which Gilroy neighborhoods offer the best value for the price?

1 Gilroy neighborhood is priced below expected value. The largest gaps are Lions Creek ($36k).

What do homes cost in Gilroy's best-value neighborhoods?

The median home price across the 1 Gilroy neighborhood priced below expected value is $1,101,890. Lions Creek, with the largest gap, has a median home price of $1,101,890.

How many Gilroy neighborhoods are priced below their expected value?

1 of 1 ranked Gilroy neighborhood with a value figure is priced below expected value, and 0 are priced above it.

How does Gilroy compare with nearby cities on home value?

100% of ranked Gilroy neighborhoods are priced below expected value. The nearest cities are Morgan Hill 75%, Santa Cruz 0%, San Jose 89%, Los Gatos 0% and Monte Sereno 0%.